Difference Between Bandsaw and Scroll Saw

Bandsaw vs Scroll Saw: Understanding the Difference If you’re in the market for a saw to cut wood, plastic, or metal, you may be considering a bandsaw or a scroll saw. While both saws are …

Bandsaw vs Scroll Saw: Understanding the Difference

If you’re in the market for a saw to cut wood, plastic, or metal, you may be considering a bandsaw or a scroll saw. While both saws are used for cutting, they have several distinct differences—such as the type of cuts they are used to make, the materials they can cut, and the size of the pieces they can handle—that you should consider before making your purchase.

Types of Cuts

The main difference between a bandsaw and a scroll saw is the type of cuts they make. A bandsaw is used to make straight, curved, and irregular cuts, while a scroll saw is used to make intricate, decorative cuts.

Bandsaws typically use a wide, continuous blade to cut through material. This type of saw is great for making straight and curved cuts in thick pieces of material. It can also make irregular cuts, such as when cutting out a hole in the middle of a piece of wood.

Scroll saws, on the other hand, use a thin blade that moves up and down to make intricate, decorative cuts. This type of saw is most commonly used for cutting intricate shapes in thin pieces of wood, plastic, or metal, such as a scroll-like pattern.

Materials

Bandsaws are typically used to cut wood, plastic, and metal, while scroll saws are mostly used to cut wood, plastic, and thin pieces of metal. Bandsaws can cut through thicker pieces of material than scroll saws, so they are better suited for larger, heavier pieces of material.

Scroll saws, on the other hand, are better suited for cutting intricate shapes in thin pieces of material. Because the blade moves up and down, scroll saws are not suitable for cutting thicker pieces of material.

Size

Bandsaws and scroll saws come in a variety of sizes. Generally, bandsaws are larger and can handle larger pieces of material than scroll saws. The size of the saw you need will depend on the type of material you are cutting and the size of the pieces you will be cutting.

Conclusion

When choosing between a bandsaw and a scroll saw, it is important to consider the type of cuts you need to make, the materials you will be cutting, and the size of the pieces you need to cut. Bandsaws are better suited for making straight, curved, and irregular cuts in thick pieces of material, while scroll saws are better suited for making intricate, decorative cuts in thin pieces of material.

1. Blade Types

The primary distinction between a bandsaw and a scroll saw is the type of blade they use. Bandsaws use a continuous loop of blade, and scroll saws use a reciprocating blade. Bandsaws are designed for cutting stock with a thickness of between 1/8” and several inches, while scroll saws are typically used for cutting thinner pieces, up to about 1/4” thick. The continuous loop of blade on a bandsaw is typically quite wide, anywhere from 1/4” to 1”, which allows for the cutting of curved shapes, including tight turns. Scroll saw blades, on the other hand, are much narrower, usually ranging from 1/16” to 1/8”, and are typically used for making intricate cuts, such as those required for scrolling designs.

2. Cutting Speed

Another major difference between a bandsaw and a scroll saw is the speed at which they cut. Bandsaws are typically much faster than scroll saws, as the continuous loop of blade allows for a much larger cutting area. On the other hand, scroll saws are limited in their cutting speed, as the reciprocating blade can only cut in a straight line. This makes them ideal for intricate cuts and delicate work, but much less suitable for larger projects.

3. Power Requirements

The power requirements of a bandsaw and scroll saw also differ significantly. Bandsaws typically require a much more powerful motor than scroll saws, as the continuous loop of blade requires more power to move. Typically, bandsaws require at least 3 HP, while scroll saws usually require between 1/2 HP and 1 HP. This means that bandsaws are typically much more expensive than scroll saws, as they require a more powerful motor and more complex design.

Leave a Comment